Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Look Who's Coming to Dinner?


Societal norms change at different paces. Some move rapidly like our immersion into the electronic age and others more slowly, such as the gradual and ongoing change in racial, gender and ethnic equality. A current cultural shift in the U.S. has taken place within a generation.

In many settings as recently as twenty years ago, the family dinner table held a level of sanctity far more hallowed and revered than telephone calls. During dinner, should the phone ring, no one bothered to answer. Evolution moved this along to the status of answering the phone only to request a return call after the shared meal. In time this gave way to answering machines picking up the call, while all the diners paused between words and bites to listen.

In modern day homes, and even more notably in restaurants, phones have established a place on table tops more prominent than napkins or silverware. During meals people openly write and receive e-mails and text messages as well as make and accept phone calls. Without question, this is a cultural shift, but to what end--productivity? Embedded in the action is the notion that whoever is at the other end of the call or electronic message holds more importance and value than the person(s) who share a table and a meal.

Use this blog to (A) note positive or negative implications to this paradigm shift or (B) suggest at least two rules for cell phone etiquette that should be followed in today’s society.

42 comments:

  1. Jacqueline Williams - OnlineMarch 2, 2010 at 4:32 PM

    I personally hate the telephone being at the table. I think that dinner should be a time for families and/or friends to come together to talk, laugh and share. It is the one thing in my family life that I keep sacred. My kids cannot watch TV, talk on the phone, listen to their iPods or anything else. Dinner is a time for us to be together. I also think it is rude for people to talk on their cell phones in a restaurant. It is maybe my biggest pet peeve when I am out. No one wants to hear you talk loudly on the telephone, or, for that matter, listen to your telephone shrill all night long. Everyone should take the time out. I can’t imagine what some people used to do before cell phones were invented. Based on their behavior, you’d think they were crazy waiting on their families and friends to be able to talk to them.

    Jacqueline Williams - Online

    ReplyDelete
  2. Suzie C. (online) I think it is rude to answer a cell phone while you are at dinner with family or friends unless there is a good reason to do so. For example, if two of you are at dinner, waiting on a third person and that person calls to ask for directions, answer the phone. But if you are at dinner with your family and your friends are calling to chat, I think the polite thing to do is answer the phone and simply say “I’m at dinner with the family, can I call you later?” This way you don’t have repeated calls, voice mail beeping, etc. This applies to family and close friends, who would not mind. However, when you are on a date, an interview or some occasion that is more formal in nature than just a routine dinner, good manners dictate that you turn your ringer down or put the phone on silent and let calls go to voicemail. If you are so important or you’re petrified that you will miss some life and death call, you can politely excuse yourself one time to go to the restroom and check your voicemail at that time. I really think we need to return to being more polite to those people who have taken the time to be with us in person. As for texting, I think it is just plain rude to text at the dinner table in front of someone else. It’s like excluding someone from a conversation. Texting was originally meant to be convenient. It was a way of getting a message to someone without interrupting what they were doing. It allowed the person to get back to you at a time of their choosing. To have to constantly reply immediately to every text you receive is just immature. Reply immediately when you don’t have anything else to do…otherwise wait a few minutes, dinner will be over soon and you can text to your hearts delight.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dinner time should be families sitting at the table eating and talking about their day. I cherish the time with my family and these days it seams dinner time is the only time since everyone has such a busy life.I do not allow phones or computers at my dinner table. It is sad how many families these days do not even sit down to dinner together and when they do, kids are on their cell phones texting with their friends. Dinner is about family not electronics. I also think that it is very rude when someone is talking on their cell phones in restaurants when people are trying to have their dinner.
    Natalya W.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Two rules for cell phone etiquette should be dont talk extermly loudly and you should have your cell phone on vibrate. You should not answer your phone at the table but if you have to answer it dont speak super loudly you have people all around you that are still having a conversation and dont need you to interrupt it. You should have your phone on vibrate so it doesn't interrupt your family discussion.
    -Radwa Hassan

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kerri Bertram (online):

    Two rules of etiquette for the use of cell phones during dinner:
    1. While eating with others, either have your phone on vibrate or silent, so it does not disturb others.
    2. If necessary to take a call, excuse yourself from the table so it isn't disrespectful to the ones in which you are eating with.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In response to Natalya W.:

    I understand where you are coming from for having dinner be a time with family and family alone, but do you eat dinner with your family every night? Why do you feel that it is so horrible for a person to see who is trying to contact them at this time? I don't think that there is a problem with someone checking their phones and need it be important allowing the communciation to continue.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tiffany Jordan online
    I think that there was positive attributes that came from the old days when the dinner table was went for family and no phones at all. I think it really made dinner at the table a family time, which now days it rare for families to even have dinner at the table. I believe that some of that tradition should be brought back because it does let families bond and talk about life. I have a daughter and i will definently spend dinner time as bonding time with no phones.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Tiffany Jordan online
    two rules for phone etiqutee
    1. don't have it at dinner
    2. Dont talk loudly if your out somewhere
    3. If you go somewhere to order food or talk to someone other than the person on the phone, hang up. i used to work at smoothie king and people talked to whole time from when i took their order to when it was done. I think that is so rude, some people just don't get it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tiffany Jordan online in response to kerri beritram
    I agree with your rules about phone etiquette.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree cell phones have their place in society. Unfortunately, many people have taken things too far. But, generally speaking, poor cell phone etiquette is just another form of bad manners and increasing disrespect for one another.

    Keith Hendershot

    ReplyDelete
  11. Everything depends on the circumstances. If you're on a date which you're suppose to direct your attention to then of course it's wrong to txt or talk on the phone, but if you're at the table eating to get rid of that growling stomach with someone you dearly know then all bets are off. Also the lifestyle needs to be put into consideration, some people have important things going on in their life which can't wait.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I don't think that cell phones have a place at the dinner table. This time should be spent with family discussing each other's lives. Today families barely see each other because they are busy doing something else. Dinner should be a time when everyone reconnects. The cell phone is a distraction and I only have one for emergency purposes. It seems like people are unable to communicate face to face anymore. All people do now is talk on their cell phones or text. You could be having a serious conversation with a person face to face but if their cell phone rings, you are thrown to the wind and ignored. If you do have to use your cell phone at the dinner table please do not make it longer than a minute to tell the other person you are having dinner and will call them back.

    Rashida Matthias online

    ReplyDelete
  13. In response to Natalya, I do not understand why you don't think it is wrong to have someone contact you at dinnertime. Maybe you don't spend dinnertime with your family, but many people do. Just let the other person and their family have this one moment every evening to connect.

    Rashida Matthias online

    ReplyDelete
  14. I am totally against answering the phne at dinner. Dinner at our home is the one time of the day yu can actually have family time. At least that hw it was when I was growing up. My children can not answer,text,etc at teh dinner table. I hate when I go to a restaurant and someone is n the phone!Collen Hester

    ReplyDelete
  15. In response to Natalya-Collen Hester
    I think it is wrong to answer your phone at dinner. If you are having dinner with family or friends thats not polte,it makes people feel their not as important.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jacqueline Williams - OnlineMarch 4, 2010 at 8:48 AM

    In response to Keith Hendershot:

    You are 100% correct. It is simply a sign of bad manners and disrespect. If I am talking to someone and we are supposed to be focused on each other, answer the telephone is disrespectful and I know that they just don't have any manners. If I was on a date, unless it was a complete emergency (i.e., sick child, etc.), it would be a deal breaker for me.

    Jacqueline Williams - Online

    ReplyDelete
  17. I rarely get the chance to eat dinner with my family so when I do I make sure my phone is either on vibrate or in my purse. Unfortunately I need my phone with in reach because I am always on call for work, but if I do get a call I leave the room and speak. I think we've gotten too comfortable having phones for more than just emergencies or for work, they are more like toys. But it is sad that some families don't sit down for dinner together anymore. I've had friends who when its time for dinner eat in separate rooms and email and text one another when its time to eat or do anything. I agree with everyone's rules about cell-phone etiquette, but in some cases you do need in within reach for very important calls.
    cheyenne m

    ReplyDelete
  18. Craig Z.

    Cell phones have taken over in today's society. It is considered to be a postive and a negative. I think it all depends on the situation. If you have gone out to eat I think you should step outside to take your call or wait. Everyone hates that person who talks really loud on the phone in a resturant. One its annoying and two it isn't necessary. Texting isn't as much of a nuisance. You can make the text quick and harmless. So it all depends on the situation. Electronics are the way of the future.

    ReplyDelete
  19. When I was younger (around 5 years ago or so) my parents use to get SO mad when I went out to eat w them because I would sit on my phone and text my best friend the entire time. I didn't realize how annoying this was until a good while later when someone(conveniently it was actually my best friend) started doing it to me! So now I don't even take my phone in when we go out to eat unless I have to. I can remember eating at home when I was growing up and everyone would get mad that the phone rang while we were eating, like people were suppose to know not to call right now (well, usually it was telemarketers calling then anyway, other families were actually sitting down eating at that time too).
    It seems like people are on such different schedules than each other in families that often they can't eat together (one parent gets off work too late to wait for if you have kids..) So if you're going to go out to eat (or even at home) Don't take your phone with you unless its absolutely necessary. Put it on vibrate so it doesnt disturb everyone else if it does ring, and walk away from the table if you pick it up! Go outside and talk if your at a restaurant. The best are people who eat by themselves. Now don't get me wrong there is nothing wrong with this (I eat by myself w no problem) but there are some that will talk on the phone the entire time theyre sitting there, including when they are eating! If you feel so uncomfortable when youre out by yourself that you have to be on the phone to feel like your not alone, go through a drive through. :)
    Ashley Lawson

    ReplyDelete
  20. Rules society should follow:
    1. Keep your phone out of sight and on silent. It is rude if you are too busy on your phone while around others, essentially you're saying to the people you’re with, the text message or email is more important than they are.
    2. If you must accept a phone call while at the table, first excuse yourself from the table, BEFORE answering the phone!!! You are with family, friends, co-workers, etc. show them respect, after all the person on the phone will be there when you answer if not you can call them back as soon as you step out of the room/ away from the table.
    ~Jasmine Maxwell

    ReplyDelete
  21. There is good and bad for using the phone or answering the phone while eating at the dinner table at home...or being out somewhere in public eating. I am a mother and for that reason my phone is constantly attached to me. My son has a cell phone and I want him to know if I am not with him he can call me at anytime...so in that case I will have my phone out and I will answer it. I have had so many weird things happen to my family memebers over the year that when the phone rings I jump for it. My dad has a heart condition and I just never know if something went wrong......my older brother died in a car wreck and we never expected that phone call but we got it....and since then I just jump when the phone rings. Now as far as blabbing on the phone to my friends while at the dinner table or out eating in public is unacceptable. But I am guilty of having that phone out or close by. I wont answer if I see it is just a friend I can call back at a later time...

    ReplyDelete
  22. Ok, so why do people believe that cell phones are so necessary? The only emergency that I can think of that I would want to have a cell phone handy would be if a family memeber or close friend was in a near fatal accident. I would want to know the moment it happened so I could be at their side as soon as possible. Any other instances where a cell phone is necessary? NO! All it allows is for everyone to be able to be bothered at any given time of the day. It makes us TOO accessable to everything and everyone. There are times when eveyone NEEDS to unwind, without any disturbance. And twenty years ago, people got along quite well without cell phones, the world turned, and society flourished. The technology today is far too much in our faces all the time. So, what are my rules of etiquite for using the cell phone at dinner? ONE...turn the phone off, and TWO...PAY ATTENTION to the people who love you enough to sit down and have a meal with you. It shows respect and concern for them. Can you tell that it bothers me that people talk on the phone when at dinner?

    I agree with Natalya W.'s comment above, I think it's sad that people don't pay attention to the people at the dinner table with them when out at restaurants, even at home. Even keeping the phone on is a distraction. When the phone rings/vibrates, you're going to be looking down at it, thinking "who's that calling? what are they calling about? is it important? should I pick up now or call back?" That's far too many questions to be asking yourself when you're supposed to be engaging in conversation with others there with you. PUT THE PHONE AWAY!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Kamilla McNac

    I was raised by my grandmother not to be disrespectful during any eating time whether it be breakfast, lunch, or dinner.Even with a snack you should take the time and say your prayers(Bless the food) and slowly enjoy the food that you are having. Of course she allowed someone to answer the phone,just because you are having dinner emergencies do not stop.We then had to take a message if it was not an emergency. And as you know we excused ourselves from the table and took the phone call. My grandmother passed last year and now my family just do what they want.I try to instill in my son the value of family meals. So I prepare every meal and we say our grace, enjoying the meal together as a family even though it is only him and I. From generation to generation things get added to and things get subtracted from. Where do they go? The family values and morals. As for proper cell phone etiquette you should 1.) always be aware of your surroundings while using the cell phone many people dont care to hear your personal conversation especially while having a meal. 2.) Try to minimize the usage of cell phones, I mean do you really have to take a phone call about what happened to Cristy at the mall today while having dinner with your family. Somethings are excusable and others are just disrespectful. Lets get it together people!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Kamilla McNac

    I was raised by my grandmother and she only allowed us to answer the phone, just because we are having dinner does not mean that the world stops.(Meaning) There will be emergencies that you could miss by not getting the phone. If it is not an emergency we were told to take a message and let the caller know that we are having dinner. My grandmother passed away last year and now I see my family doing whatever they like at any time. I still try to instill in my son and nephews the importance of saying your grace and enjoying your food respectfully. If you have to leave you may excuse yourself. As for proper etiquette for cell phone use 1.) Be aware of your surroundings while on the phone many people dont care to hear your conversation. So out of respect you should excuse yourself if you have to take the call. 2.) Minimize the cell phone usage while having a meal, I mean really do you have to take a call about what happened to Cristy at the mall. Somethings are excusable and others are just plain disrespectful. Come on people lets get it together!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  25. I think the reason we are seeing this shift from a traditional shift of family time to a more relaxed, informal and rude change is because of technology and the types of jobs that people have these days.
    I would think everyone would know two basic rules when referring to cell phones at the table, but some parents shock me.
    1) Phone on silent or vibrate and put in a holster, or pocket.
    2) If someone has to answer a call or respond to a text wait until after dinner, unless it is an emergency then excuse yourself from the table and respond to whoever need you.
    -Tyler Stevens

    ReplyDelete
  26. One of the two rules of cell phone manners would be to not use the cell phone while engaged in a conversation with someone else, buying something from the store, or any other place of business. It sends the wrong message to the person having face-to-face interaction with you that the person on the phone is more important than being with the person whom he or she is face-to-face with. Another rules is DO NOT TEXT WHILE DRIVING! I see more people swerve or get in accidents while texting than anything else! The ultimate etiquette would be not to kill someone! I don't even text myself, and when I am on the phone, it is not in front of other people.

    ~Ashton Showalter (Online Student)

    ReplyDelete
  27. Ashton Showalter's response to Candace A's post:

    I agree that when a person is in the middle of eating a meal that they most likely do not even need their cellphones. They are necessary for communication when it is needed, but it is not necessary to check Twitter every two seconds. I did not even have a cell phone until I was 17 years old. I think people can spare 30 m,minutes out of their day to sit with their family or loved ones to relax, or even to unwind from the day if they eat by themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Dana Cook - Online

    Most people with cell phones pratice no control yet alone etiquettes. One etiquette that would be nice: If you are attending a family dinner leave your cell phone in your pocket or purse on silent. Do not even bother checking your cell phone until you have completed your meal and everyone has left the table. Even then when checking your messages excuse yourself from the presence of your family. Do not check your phone in front of them. Your family should be first in your life and deserve your upmost respect. A hour is not to much time to devote undivided attention to them. Another cell phone etiquette that would be nice is when dining out and you have to have a cell phone with you due to reasons such as children being attended by a babysitter or you are on call, place the phone on viberate to respect others around you. If the phone rings, please do not answer it at the table excuse yourself and return the call from the lobby or the restroom. Talking the call at the table interrupts others while they are trying to enjoy there dining experience.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Suzie C. (online) in reply to Radwa Hassan: You hit the nail on the head. As with so many things, if people just use a little bit of common sense and respect other people's rights, the world would be a better place. Isn't it amazing to think that with all the technology, the most important thing that would make society more livable is very low tech: good manners. As my grandmother would say, good manners are not about being snooty, they are about respecting yourself and others and vice versa. I don't care if someone has to answer the cell phone, but if you have to shout to hear, or you have a loud voice, go outside.

    ReplyDelete
  30. In my opinion I find that answering a text or phone call during a meal is rude. If you are sitting with friends or family during a meal you shouldnt have your phone out and be waiting for a call. You should either leave it in your pocket on silent or in your room during this time. I find this especially rude when sitting with your family at dinner either at home or in a resturaunt. The only time you should be checking your phone at that time is if theres an emergency.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Antoryeal Nunley "ONLINE"......I personally feel that you do not need the telephone at the dinner table because if you are sharing that time with loved ones why would you want to break up that moment for the phone. Family time is very important. On the other hand you have those times where you have to pick up your phone especially if you are a physician or have some other occupation that requires you to pick up that phone. When work call you must answer.
    My two rules for dinner time will be:Place your phone on vibrate when you are at the table with family and 2, If a call must come in go into another room to take the call. Do not take away from the family.

    Antoryeal Nunley"ONLINE"

    ReplyDelete
  32. I know in my home its not abnormal to see us all with a our cell phones either in our pockets or on the table for us its not rude, but our families dinners are very casual and are normaslly done on the couch. If someone is at a restaurant even I consider it rude if they are on the phone and being loud,, however I remember a time i went to a chinese buffet and a guy was sitting alone in the corner talking quietly on his bluetooth not bothering anyone. As far as if i was eating with someone and they had their cell phone I would not be offended, whether it was my friend in which if he got a call it could be more important then just eating lunch with a buddy, or a professional who could have a family emercency or a business emercency. Now constant texting or checking of a phone I do consider rude as it seems like you are bored and tired of the conversation or the person you are with.

    ReplyDelete
  33. When i was growing up there was no answering the phone at the table no talking on the phone at the table and no texting at the table. As i got older thought, say around 17 family dinners got to be scarce. My dad either was working or playing video games ont he computer. My mom was either working or running me and my sister to some kind of sporting event and my little brother stayed n his room playing video games. SO if there was a rare chance we got to sit down and have a family dinner there were cell phones. Yes, society has changed and lost many of the morals my generations should of grown up with. When and if i do have kids there will be no cell phones or talking on the phone at the table. Research shows when a family sits down at the table it benifits kids in school and parents at work. Not to metntion the family time you get to share and learn more about each other instead of being so distant.
    stephanie smithwick

    ReplyDelete
  34. If you really feel like its that important to answer the phone you need to excuse yourself from the table and quickly return. And DO NOT reply to txt messages at the table, especially if your eating with my father.. B/c "nothing sent in a txt message is that important to reply back to right away".

    ReplyDelete
  35. Cell phone usage while dining represents poor table etiquette. Unless one is expecting an important call (i.e. business, an expecting wife, an important hospital call, etc.)one should ignore all calls and set the phone on vibrate. It is extremely rude to one's company to answer a call; it disrupts conversation, mood, and others around you.

    ReplyDelete
  36. I believe that cell phone usage is an awesome thing. I do think that it does get in the way of things. Having your phone with you at places can let you be able to keep in touch with people just in case something bad, important or whatever happens. I honestly do always have my phone and I do check it and answer it maybe if need be no matter where I am at.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Araceli Tran (Online)March 15, 2010 at 2:35 PM

    I believe its rude to answer your cell phone at the dinner table.
    B) 1. If you're with family or friends take the call and tell them you'll call them back later. If you're at a business dinner or special occasion and its a matter of life and death then excuse yourself from the table and take the call outside so you don't disrupt any conversations.
    2. When having dinner with whomever assure yourself that your cell phone is on vibrate. There is no need for everyone to know someone is calling you.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Araceli Tran (Online)March 15, 2010 at 2:43 PM

    In response to Jason Ricker

    I agree most of the time I have my phone in my pocket and so does my husband and I'd say my family as well. If I were at a business dinner it wouldn't bother me at all if the other person excuses him/her self to answer the phone. (that's my opinion everyone has different views). At restaurants I often see people talking on the phone..It only bothers me when they're talking in a very loud voice that someone on the other side of the restaurant can hear them.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Jami Phelps:
    although i admit to using my phone at a table before, i think it is horrible table manners. Society has made it so accepted because of the advancement of technology. I think we should keep our phones off the table and it should be polite to NOT answer the phone at dinner or on a date.

    ReplyDelete
  40. In my family dinner time has always been a time when we sit down together, pray for before our meal and thank God for what he has blessed us with that day and anything else that may be going on at that time, and enjoy the company of the family. Depending on if my parents were expecting an important call or if they just didn't feel like answering the phone at that time , it was acceptable to answer a call. But as for my sisters and I, it is considered rude and disrespectful to family members or guests to answer an unnecessary call that can wait until the meal is over.

    ReplyDelete
  41. If your at a family dinner don't bring your cellphone to the table. If the house phone rings only answer if necessary, For instance if you've been expecting a call from a doctor or someone living long distance

    When your out at a restaurant with company keep your phone on silent or vibrate but if it's an emergency call excuse yourself from the table to answer then upon return apologize to your company for the interruption

    ReplyDelete